In the odd video embedded above, NY Times tech columnist David Pogue compared the iPad and Kindle 3–deciding that it is impossible to compare them.

Earlier this week Pogue ruled that “the new Kindle offers the best E Ink screen, the fastest page turns, the smallest, lightest, thinnest body and the lowest price tag of any e-reader. It’s also the most refined and comfortable,” Pogue posted that odd video.”

What do you think? Is this an iPad commercial or an effective critique of the future of eReading?